Avulsion Fracture of Extensor Carpi Radialis Brevis Insertion: A Case Report and Review of Literature
Shafa Orthopedic Journal: February 2017,
4 (1); e9917
January 8, 2017
Article Type: Case Report
December 4, 2016
December 23, 2016
December 28, 2016
B. Avulsion Fracture of Extensor Carpi Radialis Brevis Insertion: A Case Report and Review of Literature,
Shafa Ortho J.
Avulsion of extensor carpi radialis brevis (ECRB) insertion from dorsal base of the third metacarpal with or without bony chips is rarely reported.
The current study reported the case of a young male that after falling down the stairs, referred to emergency room with dorsal wrist pain and weakness in wrist extension, and the lateral X-ray showed a bone fragment of dorsal capitate, but the computed tomography (CT) scan proved that the fragment was detached from the third metacarpal base. Then, with the diagnosis of ECRB avulsion fracture of its metacarpal base, the patient was operated and the fragment and accompanying tendon were fixed with 3 k-wires to its anatomic location and after 6 weeks of casting the pins were removed and at 6 months post-operation the range of motion and strength were the same as those of contralateral side.
ECRB avulsion is a rare condition, and its diagnosis can be difficult, and it should be in differential diagnosis of wrist trauma with tenderness on the base of the third metacarpal bone.
Copyright © 2017, Iran University of Medical Sciences. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits copy and redistribute the material just in noncommercial usages, provided the original work is properly cited.
Avulsion fracture of the base of the third metacarpal with retraction of extensor carpi radialis brevis (ECRB) tendon is a rare event that only 9 of these cases were previously reported (
1). Dorsal wrist swelling and an avulsion of a bony fragment dorsally accompanied by pain characterize it with a previous trauma history ( 1).
Avulsion fracture of extensor carpi radialis longus (ECRL) is a similar injury reported in the literature with reference to classic ECRB avulsion, either concomitant or isolated (
2. Case Presentation
The current study was approved by the ethics board of the institution and the patient signed written consent to publish the case report. A 24-year-old male graphic student came to emergency room of Shafa Hospital with right wrist pain after falling while going down the stairs, with a 5 cm × 5 cm ecchymosis mild swelling on dorsum of wrist and intact overlying skin and minor limitation in passive range of motion, but weak dorsiflexion and intact neurovascular status. There was no history of concomitant rheumatologic or osteoporotic diseases, but had a history of testosterone and creatine abuse 5 years prior to the accident, for body building, only for a short time. The wrist was neither deviated nor deformed and the digits were all normal. Plain radiographs showed nearly normal wrist anterior-posterior view (
Figure 1), and a 3 mm × 10 mm bony fragment on dorsum of capitate in lateral view ( Figure 2), which its origin could not be found with certainty, the computed tomography (CT) scan showed the void area at the base of the metacarpal and suggested that the fragment can be the base of the third metacarpal bone ( Figure 3). The patient was prepared for surgical exploration and with a longitudinal incision on the dorsal aspect of the third metacarpus and more proximally, the fragment exposed, showed that the ECRB tendon was still attached to the fragment and some soft tissue adhesions prevented the fragment to be migrated more proximally and the articular surface was split in half ( Figure 4).Then the fragment accompanying its tendon were reinserted anatomically and fixed with 3 K-wires; then a short arm cast was applied to immobilize the wrist in 30 degree dorsiflexion ( Figure 5). After 6 weeks of casting, the fracture was united nicely and the pins were removed ( Figure 6). With no physical therapy the wrist gained full active range of motion and strength in 6 months post-operatively.
Figure 1. Anterior-Posterior Radiograph of Wrist
Figure 2. Lateral Radiograph of the Wrist Shows the Avulsion
Figure 3. CT Scan Shows Void Area at the Base of the 3rd Metacarpal Bone
Figure 4. Intraoperative Finding Shows Avulsion of the Base of 3rd Metacarpal Bone
Figure 5. Postoperative Radiograph After Open Reduction and Fixation With 3 K-Wires
Figure 6. After Pin Removal, the Avulsion Healed
In spite of fractures of proximal first metacarpus, that is very well described (
2), very little is written about the third one with a mechanism of flexion moment of wrist with contraction of ECRB for avulsion ( 1, 3). Diagnosis of an isolated ECRB rupture is difficult ( 2, 3). The base of the third metacarpal is surrounded by neighboring joints and very strong transverse interosseous and capsular ligaments ( 3- 7), and also concave joint dorsally and ECRB attaching next to a short styloid ( 5); therefore, avulsion is more prevalent than dislocation. Also, ECRB is more effective for wrist extension than ECRL because of moment arm and not being affected by elbow position ( 4). Besides abrupt acceleration and deceleration of the tendons for rupture, fluoroquinolone antibiotics are also a cause of tendon rupture especially in Achilles tendon ( 8); the tendinitis and use of steroids and creatine are also considered ( 8). Although congruity of the joint is not very important, since there is little movement in the joint ( 2), open reduction of the fragment is recommended due to the intra articular nature of the fragment ( 2). Reattaching the fragment may also prevent extensor tendon abrasion and bossing ( 3). Many types of reattaching the tendon and the fragment are described; cerclage wiring and K-wires ( 4), anchor sutures and screw ( 3), tension band wiring ( 7), anchor suture ( 1), and tension band ( 9). ECRB can also be detached from the fragment and further anchor suturing is needed ( 3). But there was a report not being able to bring ECRB back to its normal insertion site after 12 days and attaching it side to side to ECRL led to loss of grip strength and active motion ( 3). Even conservative treatment of the patient with removal of the fragment is reported ( 6). The current study was on a traumatic isolated lesion of the wrist ECRB, the muscle and the tendon inserted on the third metacarpus. Literature review revealed 9 case reports in addition to the current patient ( 1). In the present case ECRB was completely attached to the fragment, but there were reports showing partial tendon detachment from the fragment ( 2). Advocating a surgical treatment is controversial, but since ECRB is the main wrist extensor while ECRL is radial deviating extensor and elbow flexor ( 1), to achieve wrist extension and avoid unrepaired avulsion and carpometacarpal boss ( 2) prompt repair should be initiated.
It seems that this injury is more common than previously stated, and with proper surgical treatment it heals uneventfully with no complication, and more predictable outcome can be expected.